The Emperor's New Ethics

I just attended a professional development session on ethics, led by a prominent figure involved in ethics discussions within occupational therapy. The session was structured around a "socially responsive ethical decision-making model" that integrated themes of diversity, identity, power, and historical trauma. It was thoughtfully delivered, and the presenter was receptive and open to engagement. Yet by the end, I was left with a gnawing discomfort about the philosophical architecture beneath the model. It is not that I oppose reflection or the thoughtful inclusion of cultural context. Most clinicians I know already approach their work with thoughtfulness and recognize that each patient brings a unique context worthy of consideration. But what I encountered during this session was not a pluralistic ethics framework. It was a carefully constructed worldview that strongly nudges moral reasoning toward alignment with current sociopolitical trends—while still presenting itself as...