From Social Justice to Coercive Virtue

Several years ago, I wrote about the confusion that arises when occupational therapy conflates charity with social justice and about the subtle but important shift from the Social Gospel tradition toward a politicized discourse of redistribution and equity At the time, some dismissed these concerns as overly semantic. But the receipts are there: once you build “social justice” into the profession's Code of Ethics , you’re no longer talking about voluntary altruism. You’re talking about mandatory redistribution. And now, as discussion emerges on academic listservs about the decline of student volunteerism , some are discovering that not all students are enthusiastic about forced redistribution. So, what’s the next move? You start mandating volunteerism. Think about that for a moment. Mandatory volunteerism. That phrase itself is a contradiction so sharp it should stop us in our tracks. If the goal is charity , it cannot be compelled because coerced charity is ...